Arijeta Kukic Successfully Moves To Preclude Disability Claims In A Medical Malpractice Case
Arijeta Kukic obtained a preclusion order barring plaintiff from introducing any evidence from the Social Security Administration regarding her alleged disability. Plaintiff claimed she was deemed disabled as a result of the alleged malpractice. Ms. Kukic argued that plaintiff’s repeated failure to produce the required Social Security Disability records or a valid authorization warranted preclusion. The Court agreed, finding that plaintiff’s conduct constituted willful and contumacious noncompliance under CPLR 3126. The Judge further held that defendants were prejudiced by their inability to obtain potentially critical SSA records directly bearing on plaintiff’s claims of disability and lost earnings, and determined that preclusion was an appropriate and warranted sanction.
