Mar 10th, 2026

FKB’s Emily DePaola and Andrew Jones Secures Complete Dismissal in SDNY Legal Malpractice Action


FKB is pleased to report a significant litigation victory in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York. Emily DePaola and Andrew Jones successfully obtained a Rule 12 motion to dismiss before Judge John G. Koeltl in a legal malpractice action arising from an underlying matrimonial matter involving an attorney for the child.

The Court dismissed all 18 claims asserted by the plaintiff, concluding that the action must be dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and further held that the claims were not properly alleged.

The plaintiff’s complaint attempted to challenge issues connected to ongoing state court custody proceedings. FKB, along with co-defendants, moved to dismiss the case under several federal doctrines, arguing that the plaintiff was improperly seeking to re-litigate or circumvent state court determinations through federal litigation.

Judge Koeltl agreed. The Court held that the plaintiff’s federal claims were barred under the Rooker-Feldman doctrine, which prohibits federal courts from reviewing or overturning state court judgments. The Court also applied Younger abstention, finding that the plaintiff’s requests for injunctive and declaratory relief would improperly interfere with ongoing family court proceedings.

The Court further concluded that even if it were to exercise subject matter jurisdiction, the complaint would still fail on the merits. Specifically, the Court adopted defendants’ arguments that the plaintiff’s RICO and §1985 conspiracy claims were wholly conclusory and therefore insufficient. The Court also dismissed the plaintiff’s §1983 claim, finding that the complaint failed to adequately allege that FKB’s client as a state actor, a necessary element of such a claim.

This decision represents a decisive early-stage victory for the defense and underscores the strength of the arguments advanced in the motion to dismiss. FKB congratulates Emily DePaola and Andrew Jones on this excellent Rule 12 win and the successful defense of the firm’s client in a complex and highly contested federal action.