FKB’s Rachel Aghassi And Benjamin Oxenburg Obtain Rare Federal Court Pre-Answer Dismissal For Attorney Sued Following A Real Estate Cyber Scam
02/13/2026
FKB’s Rachel Aghassi and Benjamin Oxenburg contributed to the development of novel case law by obtaining a dismissal from the Eastern District of New York on behalf of its client, a boutique real estate law firm based in Coney Island, Brooklyn and sued after cyber scammers stole nearly half of the proceeds of a real estate sale. The decision represents one of the first times a New York federal district court has dismissed an attorney from a wire fraud related case on privity grounds.
The Plaintiff, a national title insurance company, instituted a lawsuit against FKB’s client and a Long Island based title agency in connection with a May 2022 real estate transaction in Sheepshead Bay. FKB’s client represented the seller of the property, and the title agency issued a title policy on behalf of and underwritten by the Plaintiff. The seller’s property was encumbered by two (2) mortgages which needed to be satisfied at the closing. In the days leading up to the closing, unknown actors impersonated a representative from the lender holding the seller’s mortgages and circulated fraudulent payoff instructions to the seller and to FKB’s client. At the closing, the title agency’s closer called the phone number on the fraudulent payoff instructions and left a message. After receiving a call back purporting to confirm the payoff instructions, the title closer authorized a wire transfer without using independent sources to verify the phone number called, in violation of various underwriting alerts and communications from Plaintiff which warned its agents to be vigilant against these exact kinds of scams. Plaintiff then waited a year before fulfilling its obligations under the title policy and sending funds to satisfy the outstanding mortgages. Several months later Plaintiff instituted its lawsuit in the Eastern District, alleging that FKB’s client had voluntarily assumed a duty to provide accurate payoff instructions and breached that duty by representing that the fraudulent instructions were accurate. Plaintiff sought to recover the amount it was compelled to pay to satisfy the mortgages, which by that time had increased to over $450,000, approximately $100,000 more than the wire sent at the closing.
Magistrate Judge Robert M. Levy issued a detailed report recommending that FKB’s FRCP 12(b) motion be granted and the negligence/professional malpractice, negligent misrepresentation, and indemnification claims be dismissed against the attorney. Magistrate Judge Levy agreed with FKB’s arguments, finding that Plaintiff had failed to substantiate the claim that FKB’s client agreed to accept any duty to Plaintiff at any time and that there was a lack of contractual privity or allegations of near privity. Magistrate Judge Levy was particularly persuaded by FKB’s citation to and discussion of a nearly factually identical New York state case involving the same Plaintiff, in which it unsuccessfully made the same assumption of duty arguments against a seller’s attorney in a similar real estate closing gone wrong.
District Judge Nina R. Morrison agreed with Magistrate Judge Levy’s thorough and well-reasoned report and issued a decision adopting it in its entirety and dismissed the claims against FKB’s client with prejudice. Judge Morrison considered Plaintiff’s privity and assumption of duty arguments de novo and confirmed that they lacked merit. Judge Morrison was similarly swayed by the authority supplied by FKB, acknowledging that while it was not strictly binding on the Court as a state Supreme Court case, its reasoning was instructive and highly persuasive.
With Judge Morrison’s decision, this case became the one of the first federal dismissals of an attorney facing a cyber scam claim, and the first such federal decision in New York on these facts.
If you have any questions about this decision, cyber security & privacy, or the defense of attorneys in general, please contact Rachel Aghassi and Benjamin Oxenburg.
