FKB’s Spencer A. Richards and David P. Furman Obtain Dismissal of Claims Against Law Firm in Real Estate Investment Dispute
FKB’s Spencer A. Richards and David P. Furman recently obtained the dismissal of all claims asserted against a law firm client in a New York County Supreme Court action arising from a real estate investment and attempted tax-deferred exchange. The Court granted FKB’s motion to dismiss in its entirety pursuant to CPLR 3211.
The plaintiff alleged that FKB’s client and other defendants participated in a scheme that prevented it from completing an intended Internal Revenue Code § 1031 exchange involving one property and induced it to invest in another. The plaintiff further alleged that the resulting transaction did not qualify for the intended tax treatment.
FKB moved to dismiss the claims against its client pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(5) and (7), arguing that the fraud-based claims were barred by the applicable statute of limitations. The Court agreed, finding that the plaintiff had sufficient information by March 2020 to investigate the alleged fraud, more than two years before commencing the action, and therefore could not rely on the two-year discovery rule under CPLR 213(8). The Court also dismissed the General Business Law § 349 claim as untimely.
The Court further held that the complaint failed to state claims against the firm for negligence per se and constructive trusts. The statutes cited by the plaintiff did not impose the alleged duty on the firm, and the complaint did not allege a transfer of the plaintiff’s funds or property to the firm.
For more information about this decision or FKB’s professional liability practice, please contact Spencer A. Richards or David P. Furman.
