Aug 11th, 2026

FKB’s Spencer A. Richards And David P. Furman Secured A Significant Appellate Victory Before The New York State Appellate Division, Second Department, Affirming The Dismissal Of Every Claim For Affirmative Damages Asserted Against FKB’s Attorney Clients. David Furman Presented Oral Argument On Behalf Of The Clients


FKB’s Spencer A. Richards and David P. Furman secured a significant appellate victory before the New York State Appellate Division, Second Department, affirming the dismissal of every claim for affirmative damages asserted against FKB’s attorney clients. David Furman presented oral argument on behalf of the clients.

The action arose from the clients’ representation of the plaintiff in an underlying medical malpractice action. The plaintiff alleged that his attorneys participated in a scheme with the defendants and defense counsel in the underlying action to use purportedly altered medical records to induce him to accept a settlement. He asserted numerous claims, including legal malpractice, violations of Judiciary Law § 487, fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract, and intentional infliction of emotional distress.

FKB obtained pre-answer dismissal of the claims in Kings County Supreme Court. On appeal, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of all claims seeking damages against FKB’s clients. The Court also affirmed an order granting the clients additional time to respond to the complaint and a separate order denying the plaintiff’s motion for a default judgment. The Court modified the dismissal order only to reinstate a limited declaratory judgment claim concerning the former firms’ entitlement to legal fees in the underlying medical malpractice action which remains pending.

Taken together, the decisions resolve all perfected appeals and leave no surviving claim for damages against FKB’s clients.

If you have any questions about these decisions or the defense of attorneys and other professionals, please contact Spencer A. Richards or David P. Furman.