Aug 3rd, 2026

Megan Feinberg And Michael Valdez Obtain Summary Judgment In A Wrongful Death And Medical Malpractice Action


FKB’s Megan Feinberg and Michael Valdez successfully obtained summary judgment on behalf of a home care staffing agency in an action sounding in medical malpractice and wrongful death.  The case arose from allegations that the decedent’s personal home care assistant negligently cared for her, resulting in two falls that allegedly caused injuries resulting in her death.  The matter presented a unique legal issue because FKB’s client served as the fiscal intermediary for the decedent under New York’s Consumer Directed Personal Assistance Program (CDPAP). Under the CDPAP, the patient and family select, hire, train, supervise, and, if necessary, terminate the personal assistant. Although the aide was processed as FKB’s employee for payroll purposes, Michael and Megan successfully demonstrated FKB’s client neither recruited, hired, trained, nor supervised the aide and therefore could not be held liable for her alleged negligence.

Notably, the plaintiff opposed the motion with an expert affirmation asserting that FKB’s client exercised sufficient control over the aide to create liability. The Court rejected those opinions as vague, conclusory, and unsupported by the record, holding that the plaintiff failed to raise a triable issue of fact. The Court granted summary judgment and dismissed the complaint against in its entirety.