FKB’s Aaron M. Barham and Asher Kest Secure Unanimous First Department Affirmance Dismissing High-Exposure Legal Malpractice Claim
The plaintiff alleged that FKB’s law-firm client, acting as lender’s counsel in two real-estate loan transactions, had a duty to ensure that mortgages were recorded and that valid title insurance policies were issued. In a separate, sworn Florida fraud action arising from the same transactions, however, the plaintiff expressly alleged that it retained and relied upon a third-party title agency to perform those exact functions.
FKB moved to dismiss pursuant to CPLR 3211(a)(1), arguing that the plaintiff’s own judicial admissions and undisputed closing documents conclusively refuted the existence of any such duty. FKB further argued that the losses alleged were caused by the independent fraud of the plaintiff’s chosen title agent, rather than by any act or omission of lender’s counsel.
Following a hotly contested oral argument, the First Department unanimously affirmed dismissal, holding that the plaintiff’s prior sworn allegations and the documentary record utterly refuted its malpractice claims.
If you have any questions about this matter or FKB’s professional liability and appellate practice, please contact Aaron M. Barham or Asher Kest.
