Jan 30th, 2026

FKB’s Aaron M. Barham and Dylan Diamond Secure Early Discontinuance of Legal Malpractice Counterclaims Following Motion to Dismiss


FKB’s Aaron M. Barham and Dylan Diamond secured a discontinuance with prejudice of legal malpractice counterclaims asserted against a law firm client in Westchester County Supreme Court.

The counterclaims arose from the lawyer’s representation of a former client in a post-judgment matrimonial matter and sought to reframe dissatisfaction with the terms of a settlement into claims sounding in legal malpractice. However, the claimant had expressly allocuted on the underlying record that he understood and agreed to the settlement terms, entered into the agreement voluntarily, and was satisfied with counsel’s representation.

FKB filed a pre-answer motion to dismiss pursuant to CPLR 3211, arguing that the counterclaims failed as a matter of law a party who allocutes to a settlement cannot plead proximate causation absent allegations that the settlement was “effectively compelled” by counsel’s errors. The motion further relied on the underlying allocution transcript and so-ordered stipulation of settlement, which conclusively refuted the malpractice allegations.

Following the filing of FKB’s motion, the counterclaims were discontinued with prejudice, bringing the matter to an efficient resolution.

If you have any questions about this matter or FKB’s professional liability practice, please contact Aaron M. Barham.