Feb 19th, 2026

FKB’s Aaron M. Barham and Jason H. Seiler Secure Dismissal of Accounting Malpractice Claim Arising from Expert Testimony Dispute


FKB’s Aaron M. Barham and Jason H. Seiler successfully defended an accounting malpractice action brought in federal court against a CPA retained as a damages expert in an underlying New Jersey litigation.

Plaintiffs alleged that the accountant’s failure to testify at trial caused the dismissal of their business-related claims and resulted in significant financial losses. FKB moved to dismiss, demonstrating that the underlying claims were barred by the statute of limitations and laches and thus that Plaintiffs could not plausibly establish proximate causation or actual damages.

The Magistrate Judge agreed with FKB’s causation and damages arguments and recommended dismissal of the malpractice claims. While the Report and Recommendation permitted a limited fee-related contract claim to proceed, the District Judge adopted the recommendation and dismissed the remaining claim for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, resulting in dismissal of the action in its entirety.

If you have questions about this matter or FKB’s professional liability practice, please contact Aaron M. Barham or Jason H. Seiler.