FKB’s Aaron M. Barham, Ryan Riger, and Nicolas Espinosa Secure Discontinuance With Prejudice of Legal Malpractice Action Against Workers’ Compensation Attorney
FKB recently obtained a discontinuance with prejudice of a legal malpractice action against a workers’ compensation attorney, after the plaintiff elected not to oppose FKB’s motion to dismiss.
The plaintiff, a construction worker, retained the attorney following a workplace accident. He later alleged that the attorney should have preserved and pursued a third-party Labor Law § 241(6) action against the public authority responsible for the project, and that the failure to serve a notice of claim within ninety days of the accident caused the loss of that claim.
In moving to dismiss, FKB argued that the attorney was retained solely for the workers’ compensation claim, as reflected in the Notice of Retainer and Appearance filed with the Workers’ Compensation Board, and that an attorney cannot be held liable for failing to act outside the scope of the retainer. FKB further argued that the plaintiff could not establish proximate causation because his contemporaneous records described an exertion injury sustained while loading demolition debris, with no reference to the passageway obstruction later alleged as the basis for the Labor Law claim.
Rather than oppose the motion, the plaintiff stipulated to discontinue the action with prejudice, ending the case without any payment on behalf of the attorney.
FKB regularly defends attorneys against legal malpractice claims arising from the scope of a limited engagement. For more information about FKB’s practice, please contact Aaron M. Barham.
