Oct 15th, 2026

Tracy S. Katz Secures Significant Appellate Victory In Discrimination Case Of First Impression Before The Second Department


Tracy S. Katz secured a significant appellate victory before the Appellate Division, Second Department, in a discrimination case of first impression addressing whether an alleged sexual assault by an employee constitutes discrimination under the New York City Human Rights Law (“NYCHRL”) and may subject an employer to strict liability.

FKB represented a physical therapy practice in a lawsuit alleging sexual assault and discrimination by a formerly employed physical therapy assistant. Plaintiff argued that the NYCHRL (Title 8 of the New York City Administrative Code) imposes strict liability on employers for discriminatory acts committed by their employees and sought to characterize the alleged sexual assault as discrimination under the statute.

FKB successfully argued that an alleged sexual assault does not constitute discrimination within the meaning of the NYCHRL so as to impose strict liability on the employer. The court granted FKB’s motion for summary judgment and dismissed the discrimination cause of action. Plaintiff appealed, and, in a matter of first impression, the Second Department affirmed the underlying decision, upholding FKB’s position on appeal.

The Second Department’s decision marks an important development in New York discrimination law. As plaintiff’s firms increasingly attempt to characterize sexual assault as discrimination to circumvent established principles governing employer liability, this appellate ruling upholds a critical distinction between sexual assault and discrimination under the NYCHRL. The decision reinforces the longstanding principle that an employer generally cannot be held liable for an employee’s sexual assault absent proof of actual or constructive notice of the employee’s propensity to engage in such conduct or that the conduct was undertaken in furtherance of the employer’s business.